Does Stretching Prevent Injury?

Story

Connected to · 5

cofactor · 1

Mobility & flexibility
A full-range loaded squat trains a large range of motion at the hip, knee and ankle while building strength and control within that range. Mobility backed by strength handles load better than flexibility alone, for the same reason that active control at the end of a joint's range beats passive lengthening.

antagonism · 1

Warm-up & cool-down
Holding a stretch for more than 60 seconds before exercise briefly lowers your strength and power afterward (strength by about 5% on average). For explosive sports, long static stretching before competing does little to prevent injury and costs some performance up front; dynamic movements make a better warm-up.

regulates · 2

Progressive overload
Injuries often happen when load goes up before the soft tissues have adapted, so the "progressive" in progressive overload is itself part of injury prevention. In a meta-analysis of randomized trials, stretching showed no protective effect, while strength training cut sports injuries by about two thirds.
Ankle Sprain
Proprioceptive training such as balance work and standing on one leg reduces sports injuries, while stretching does almost nothing: in a meta-analysis of randomized trials, the first clearly lowered the chance of injury and the second was about the same as doing nothing. For ankle sprains specifically, the evidence for preventing the next one is strong for bracing and moderate for neuromuscular training, and neither of them is stretching.

contrast · 1

Running for beginners
To get injured less, the main tool is strength training, not stretching before a run. In a meta-analysis of 25 randomized trials, strength training cut sports injuries by about two thirds (relative risk, RR, 0.32), while stretching had almost no effect (RR 0.96, with a confidence interval that crosses 1). For beginners, injury prevention rests on strength training plus building up volume gradually.
Mechanism · 3
Mechanism · How strength training prevents injury
To get injured less, the main tool is adding some strength training to your running, not stretching longer before a run. Stronger muscles and tendons and better control of the legs let the body withstand repeated impact; static stretching does not bring that adaptation. Lauersen 2014 compared prevention methods one by one: strength training reduced injuries, while the effect of stretching could not be told apart from zero.
Numbers · The effect of each method
Lauersen 2014 pooled 25 randomized trials, 26,610 participants and 3,464 injuries. Broken down by method, the relative risk (RR) was 0.315 for strength training (95% CI 0.207–0.480), 0.550 for proprioception training, and 0.963 for stretching (0.846–1.095), which means stretching had no effect. All exercise programs taken together also reduced acute and overuse injuries, but those are separate figures, not the effect of strength training on its own.
In practice · A beginner's injury-prevention mix
A beginner runner's injury-prevention mix is alternating running and walking, building up gradually, strengthening the legs and leaving enough time to recover; shoes just need to fit well. Stretching increases range of motion and a warm-up is useful, but neither is injury prevention. Strength training brings the risk of injury down to about a third, not to zero; building up gradually is still the first strategy for preventing injury.

Read full story

Stop 1/5

Why the stretching belief sticks

EVIDENCEREVIEW 2

READ THE ORIGINAL

"Stretch before you exercise so you don't pull something" is probably the most widely repeated advice in fitness. When researchers actually tested it, the answer was this: in pooled randomized trials, people who stretched and people who did not got injured at almost the same rate. What clearly pushed injuries down was strength training.

The advice is hard to dislodge because the intuition is so reasonable: a tight muscle should be loosened. But a strain usually happens in the instant a muscle is being lengthened while it is still contracting hard — the rear leg pushing off in a sprint, for example, when the back of the thigh is stretched and still has to produce force. What decides whether it gets hurt in that instant is how much force it still has at that length. Passive stretching trains something else: how far you can be pulled while relaxed.

There is also a counterintuitive detail. Static stretching done on its own before exercise, held for 60 seconds or more per muscle, briefly and slightly lowers the strength and power that follow (Behm 2016). The problem is the routine of stretch only, stretch long, then go straight into competition, not stretching itself.

So there is no need to throw stretching out. It widens the range your joints can move through; just do not expect it to prevent injury.

Educational content, not medical advice — consult a clinician.

Back