Story
How the body manages minerals · Gatekeeping intake or excretion
The body manages minerals two ways: iron, zinc, and copper are controlled at the gut, while excess sodium, potassium, magnesium, iodine, and selenium are cleared mainly in urine. Knowing a mineral's type shows where too much gets stuck.
Last updated
Overview and key questions
In short: Your body controls how much of a mineral it holds mainly in one of two places: either at the gut, deciding how much gets in and sending extra back into the gut, or at the kidneys, which let the surplus out in urine as needed.
Educational content, not medical advice. See a clinician about your own case.
Two places to control the total: The body controls its total of a mineral mainly in one of two places: the gut decides how much gets in, or the kidneys let the surplus out in urine.
More copper, a smaller share absorbed: Iron, zinc and copper are all controlled at the gut, and the more copper you eat, the smaller the share the gut lets in.
Healthy kidneys let the surplus out: For minerals that leave through the kidneys, the surplus goes out in urine while the kidneys are healthy.
Story path
Chapter 1
Two ways the body manages minerals
Iron, zinc and copper belong to the first group. Iron balance is kept by adjusting absorption in the upper small intestine. Copper and zinc are also absorbed to order, and on top of that their surplus can be sent back into the gut; very little of either leaves in urine.
Sodium, potassium, magnesium, iodine and selenium belong to the second group, and their surplus leaves mainly in urine. More than nine-tenths of sodium and of iodine ends up in urine, the kidneys are the main regulator of total body magnesium, and selenium is kept in balance mainly by excretion in urine.
Once you know which group a mineral is in, you can work out where an excess gets stuck. For the gut-managed ones, a shared door lets several metals crowd each other out. For the kidney-managed ones, the surplus may not be cleared when the kidneys are weak.
Swallowing a large amount of iron at once is a different matter: if a child swallows an iron-containing product, get medical care immediately or contact poison control.
Numbers · Where each mineral leaves the body
Copper: urine usually carries less than 0.1 mg a day, whether intake is high or low; the surplus is sent by the liver into bile and out into the gut.Zinc: what leaves in urine is less than a tenth of what leaves in feces; the main exit is zinc secreted into the gut in pancreatic juice and by intestinal cells.Potassium: about 77% to 90% of intake leaves in urine, and most of the rest in feces.Sodium: with little sweating and steady intake, 90% to 95% leaves in urine.Iodine: iodine in the blood is taken up mainly by the thyroid and the kidneys; the thyroid takes what it needs, and most of the rest goes into urine.Selenium: it leaves mainly in urine; at higher intakes, also in the breath and in feces.
The more firmly an exit is controlled, the less the blood level tends to move. Zinc is an example: the body holds plasma zinc in a narrow range, and even when dietary zinc drops sharply, plasma zinc can look unchanged for weeks. In trials it does move with intake, but in one person it is hard to read.
Chapter 2
Zinc and copper can leave; iron barely
The more copper you eat, the smaller the share you absorb: about 75% at only 400 µg a day, and just 12% at 7.5 mg a day. When more copper has been absorbed, the liver sends more of it into bile and back into the gut, and this step is probably the main point where total body copper is regulated.
Zinc has two layers of control. How efficiently it is absorbed is the coarse setting; how much is secreted back into the gut is the fine setting. On a low-zinc diet, less than 1 mg a day goes back into the gut; on a high-zinc diet, more than 5 mg.
Iron's exit is far smaller. Without bleeding or pregnancy, the basic daily loss is about 0.5 mg in iron deficiency and only about 2 mg even with iron overload. With losses this small, the amount of iron in your body depends on how much was absorbed, and absorption is controlled by hepcidin, a hormone made by the liver.
Evidence · Does extra iron build up in healthy people
The report gives only one clear example of iron overload from diet: people in southern Africa who drank large amounts of a traditional beer over many years. The beer held 80 mg of iron per liter on average, the iron was well absorbed, and some people drank several liters a day; members of the same communities who did not drink much of it did not develop overload. The report judged that the large iron intake played the main role, but noted there may also be a genetic factor, in a gene different from the one behind the common form of hereditary hemochromatosis.
The other kind of iron overload comes from going around the gut's door: repeated blood transfusions, iron given by injection, or certain blood disorders that speed up iron absorption.
So the main point of having no exit lies with the door itself. Hepcidin guards absorption, and iron losses are very small, so total body iron depends on absorption and its control. So the people who most need to worry about building up iron are those whose door fails to close when it should.
Chapter 3
Too much zinc keeps copper out
When a lot of zinc enters the cells lining the gut, they make more of a small metal-gripping protein called metallothionein. It grips copper even more tightly than zinc, so copper gets held inside the gut cells, cannot reach the blood, and less of it is absorbed.
The link is close enough that when US experts set the upper limit for zinc, copper was the yardstick. The basis was one study: 18 women took 50 mg of zinc a day, and after 10 weeks a copper-containing enzyme was clearly less active than before. Adding about 10 mg of zinc from the diet put the harmful intake at about 60 mg a day. Dividing that by 1.5 gives the adult upper limit: 40 mg a day, counting food and supplements together.
Zinc and copper are not the only pair. Iron at supplement doses may reduce zinc absorption, and manganese can lower iron absorption. What copper deficiency looks like, and why Wilson disease turns the same effect around and uses zinc as a drug, are covered in other stories.
Mechanism · Which metals crowd each other at the gut
Zinc and copper: large doses of zinc reduce copper absorption. The report offers two possible explanations: the two compete for the same transporter on the gut-facing side of the intestinal cell, or the metallothionein that zinc induces holds on to copper. The second is already used to treat Wilson disease, so that patients absorb less copper. In one case, an infant given 16 to 24 mg of zinc a day developed copper deficiency. Yet when people were fed zinc and copper in ratios of 2 to 1, 5 to 1 and 15 to 1, the effect on copper absorption was limited. What to watch, then, is zinc far above dietary amounts, not the ratio in an ordinary diet.
Iron and zinc: iron at the levels found in some supplements, taken daily, may reduce zinc absorption, a concern when iron is given in pregnancy and breastfeeding. The report notes that in iron deficiency the gut makes more of an iron transporter whose affinity for zinc is similar to its affinity for iron, which may be one place where the two interact; this is still a hypothesis.
Manganese and iron: manganese lowered iron absorption, both from a solution and from a hamburger meal. In the other direction, a study saw that people with lower plasma absorbed more manganese, an association that was observed rather than tested.
Taken together, the conclusion is simple: high-dose single-mineral supplements of these metals are the most likely to cause knock-on problems at this door.
Chapter 4
When the kidneys falter, the risk flips
Magnesium shows this best. The kidneys are the main organ managing magnesium: when magnesium runs short, the amount in urine falls very low within three to four days, and when intake is high, the kidneys let the extra go. So in people without intestinal or kidney disease, there are no records of high blood magnesium even from large amounts of magnesium-rich food. High blood magnesium is most often seen when poor kidney function is combined with a lot of magnesium from non-food sources, such as magnesium-containing antacids and laxatives.
Potassium works the same way. With normal kidneys, extra potassium from food is quickly excreted in urine, and for that reason the 2005 US report set no upper limit for potassium from food. In people with chronic kidney disease (), or who take ACE inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blockers or potassium-sparing diuretics, potassium is harder to excrete, and rising blood potassium can cause heart rhythm problems. These people should ask their doctor before changing their diet or taking potassium; the details are covered in other stories.
Clinical · Why weak kidneys mean asking first
The 1997 report of the US Institute of Medicine (IOM) also records deaths from very large doses of magnesium sulfate or magnesium oxide, especially in people with kidney insufficiency.
Potassium: the 2005 US report lists common drugs that can substantially impair potassium excretion, namely ACE inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blockers and potassium-sparing diuretics, and conditions that do the same: diabetes, chronic kidney insufficiency, end-stage kidney disease, severe heart failure and adrenal insufficiency. Older adults often have one or more of these, so their risk of high potassium is higher. The report adds that such people, usually under medical supervision, are better served by a potassium intake below the general recommendation.
The kidneys also handle potassium unevenly. When blood potassium rises even slightly, healthy kidneys excrete it quickly; when potassium intake is low, they are not good at holding on to it. So normal kidneys guard against high potassium but not against potassium deficiency.
Mechanism · Manganese leaves through bile
So the 2001 report of the US Institute of Medicine (IOM) notes that the risk of manganese toxicity is highest when bile excretion is low, as in newborns and people with liver disease. People with chronic liver disease show the neurological pathology and behavior of manganese neurotoxicity, probably because impaired bile excretion raises blood manganese, which then reaches the brain on transferrin. Too much manganese in long-term intravenous nutrition has also been linked to manganese toxicity.
Copper's exit is also through bile. When a genetic mutation disables the copper pump that moves copper from liver cells into bile, copper piles up inside the cells. The disease is called Wilson disease.
Chapter 5
Narrow for selenium, wide for magnesium
Magnesium wins on both. Magnesium in food has never been found to cause harm, and with normal kidneys the extra leaves in urine. Too much magnesium from supplements and medicines first causes osmotic diarrhea, which is mild, clears up by itself, and is noticed at once. So its upper limit covers only non-food sources, 350 mg a day, with almost no extra safety margin taken off.
Selenium loses on both. The gut does not hold it back: more than nine-tenths of selenomethionine, the main form in food, is absorbed. It also passes for methionine and gets built at random into all kinds of proteins, a step that is not regulated, which leaves excretion in urine as the main thing the body can adjust.
The adult recommended intake for selenium is 55 µg a day and the upper limit is 400 µg. The limit comes from dividing 800 µg a day, the level with no observed harm, by 2, because harms such as hair loss and brittle nails may not reverse. What selenium poisoning looks like, and how much selenium Brazil nuts carry, are covered in another story.
Numbers · What the two upper limits rest on
Magnesium: in 1997 the US Institute of Medicine (IOM) chose diarrhea as the key harm. Among 21 patients aged 51 to 70 who took 360 mg of magnesium a day as magnesium chloride over the long term, 6 developed diarrhea and other gut symptoms, so 360 mg was taken as the lowest harmful dose. The factor was set at about 1.0, because osmotic diarrhea is mild, reversible and obvious to the person, so it does not quietly progress until serious harm shows. The limit was set at 350 mg a day, counting only supplements and medicines. The report also notes that many people take far more than this without trouble.
Selenium: in 2000 the IOM chose brittle, falling hair and nails as the key harm. The data came from 5 patients with selenium poisoning re-examined by Chinese researchers. At their first examination, the lowest blood selenium matched an intake of about 913 µg a day. Six years later they were described as recovered from selenium poisoning, though their fingernails reportedly still looked brittle, and their blood selenium matched about 800 µg a day, which was taken as the level with no observed harm. The factor was set at 2, to protect sensitive people and because this harm is not severe but may not reverse easily.
Compare them and the gap is clear. The magnesium limit sits almost at the dose that causes diarrhea, while the selenium limit is cut to half of the no-harm level, which leaves it only a little more than seven times the recommended intake. The report spells out its reasons and doubts: the harm may not reverse, sensitive people need protecting, the data come from only 5 patients, and those patients may not be typical.
Chapter 6
What excess does depends on the route
1. Managed at the gut (iron, zinc, copper): the more you take, the smaller the share absorbed, but high-dose single-mineral supplements taken for a long time can crowd other metals out at the same door; zinc pushing copper aside is the classic case. Iron's exit is also very small, so most of the iron that gets in is kept by the body.
2. Cleared by the kidneys (sodium, potassium, magnesium, iodine, selenium): while the kidneys are healthy, the extra leaves in urine. With poor kidney function the risk flips for magnesium and potassium, and for potassium also with several drugs that make the kidneys hold on to it. Ask a doctor before supplementing. Selenium is the special case in this group: the gut does not hold it back and its window is narrow, so add up food and supplements together.
The grouping only tells you where the excess goes, not whether it does harm on the way. Most iodine leaves in urine, yet its upper limit is based on how the thyroid responds. How upper limits are set, and how several supplements stack past them, are covered in another story.
One more point has nothing to do with groups: if a child swallows an iron-containing product, get medical care immediately or contact poison control.
Myth · Low absorption makes big doses safe
The right half: for many minerals the share absorbed does fall as intake rises; this holds for copper and zinc, and for magnesium too.
The wrong half: a smaller share still means a growing total. The IOM states that the absolute amount of copper absorbed rises with intake, and zinc is the same: as intake rises, the amount absorbed increases while the share drops. The part that is not absorbed is not harmless either: magnesium left in the gut draws water into it and causes osmotic diarrhea.
Selenium lacks even the right half: its absorption is not regulated, so the share does not fall as you take more.
So the better questions are these: once the extra gets in, does it have an exit; and the part that stays out, will it cause trouble in the gut?
References (7)
- Institute of Medicine. (2001). Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin A, Vitamin K, Arsenic, Boron, Chromium, Copper, Iodine, Iron, Manganese, Molybdenum, Nickel, Silicon, Vanadium, and Zinc. National Academies Press. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK222310
- Institute of Medicine. (2005). Dietary Reference Intakes for Water, Potassium, Sodium, Chloride, and Sulfate. National Academies Press. nap.nationalacademies.org/catalog/10925/dietary-reference-intakes-for-water-potassium-sodium-chloride-and-sulfate
- Institute of Medicine. (1997). Dietary Reference Intakes for Calcium, Phosphorus, Magnesium, Vitamin D, and Fluoride. National Academies Press. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK109825
- National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements. (2021). Selenium — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Selenium-HealthProfessional
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. (1997). Iron-containing supplements and drugs: Label warning statements and unit-dose packaging requirements (Final rule; Docket Nos. 91P-0186 and 93P-0306). Federal Register, 62(10), 2218–2250. www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-1997-01-15/html/97-947.htm
- Ganz, T. (2013). Systemic iron homeostasis. Physiological Reviews, 93(4), 1721–1741. 10.1152/physrev.00008.2013
- Institute of Medicine. (2000). Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin C, Vitamin E, Selenium, and Carotenoids. National Academies Press. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK225483
Written from the sources listed above. Checked sentence by sentence against them in . No physician reviews this site: it explains how the body works, and it is not medical advice. How we make content
Spotted an error, or something unclear? Email us. We read every message, check it against the sources, and fix what's wrong.