Isoflavones look like estradiol and can sit in the estrogen receptor, but they activate it orders of magnitude more weakly.
Full mechanism, in text
What phytoestrogens are
1. Shaped like estradiol, so it fits the chair
The main soy isoflavones, genistein and daidzein, look somewhat like the body's own estrogen, , so they can bind estrogen receptors.That is why they are called phytoestrogens, and the name has misled a lot of people: being able to sit in estrogen's chair is not the same as being estrogen.
2. In the chair, barely a push
Isoflavones activate the receptor orders of magnitude more weakly than the body's own estrogen: same chair, barely a push.So binding is not the same as acting like estrogen. Isoflavones are not the estrogen you might imagine.
3. Two receptors, and isoflavones prefer ERβ
The body has two estrogen receptors, ERα and ERβ; works on both, while isoflavones prefer ERβ.Based on cell and animal studies, ERα is the main driver of cell growth in the breast and uterus, while ERβ often acts as a brake in many tissues.
So isoflavones behave like a plant molecule with selective effects, somewhat like the drugs called selective estrogen receptor modulators: in different tissues they may act slightly like estrogen or work against it, depending on the local receptor type and the body's own estrogen level.
4. Gut bacteria make people differ
Some people's gut bacteria turn daidzein into equol, a more active product, so two people eating the same tofu can respond differently.Only some people carry those bacteria, and the share is higher in Asian populations. That partly explains why results differ from person to person and from study to study.
The chapters on soy and men and on breast cancer test this mechanism against the human evidence.