Story
Falling asleep is driven by sleep pressure, the body clock, and stress, and each sleep supplement touches only one of them, mostly with evidence from small trials. The first choice for chronic insomnia is still cognitive behavioral therapy.
regulates (6)
Melatonin sits on the body-clock link of sleep control: it is the body's nightfall signal, and taking it mainly changes what time you start to feel sleepy. Used for ordinary insomnia, it brought sleep forward by only about 4 minutes on average in one meta-analysis.
Glycine is placed on the pre-sleep cool-down link: in rats, taking it by mouth increases blood flow to the skin and lowers core temperature. In people there are only a few small trials, and the cooling step has not been measured directly in people.
Theanine is often placed on the brain's GABA brake, a position that comes from animal experiments. In a crossover trial that looked at sleep directly, only three parts of a sleep questionnaire differed from placebo.
Magnesium is often said to act on the GABA brake. In three randomized trials in older adults, it helped people fall asleep about 17 minutes sooner, with no difference in total sleep time, and the evidence was of low to very low quality.
Ashwagandha sits on the stress link of sleep control: in stressed adults who took it, serum cortisol fell. There are case reports of liver injury, and people who already had chronic liver disease fared worst.
A foot soak and glycine touch the same cool-down link. Before lights out, the blood vessels in the skin of the hands and feet open to release heat, core temperature falls, and you grow sleepy. A foot soak warms the hands and feet from outside.
contrast (2)
The first-line treatment for chronic insomnia is cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, not sleep supplements. Its sleep-restriction component is designed to strengthen sleep pressure, and none of the common sleep supplements adds that pressure directly.
The brain really does use GABA to hold back firing, but there are no human data on whether eaten GABA reaches synapses in the brain. Evidence on sleep from 14 trials is also very limited.