Glycogen travels with water · how the scale swings without fat
Full mechanism, in text
Glycogen travels with water
1. Glucose is linked into glycogen
The carbohydrate you eat is digested into glucose, and the liver and muscles link part of it into long chains for storage: this is glycogen.All the glycogen in the body adds up to only a few hundred grams, most of it in muscle. A review written for coaches and athletes gives typical values: muscle holds about 500 g on average (range 300–700 g), the liver about 80 g (0–160 g), and the whole body about 600 g, with large differences depending on body mass, diet, fitness and recent exercise.
2. Glycogen is not stored dry
Every gram of glycogen stored takes at least 3 g of water in with it.The ratio of 3 g of water per gram of glycogen has been rechecked with muscle biopsies. Nine aerobically trained people cycled for 150 minutes in the heat and dehydrated by about 4.6%; their muscle water fell by about 13% and muscle glycogen by about 44%. When they then took in carbohydrate, muscle stored roughly three parts water for each part of glycogen. In the round where they drank enough to replace their losses, the ratio rose as high as one to seventeen, and the authors think the extra water was probably not bound to glycogen. The study had only 9 people, looked only at muscle, and only at the first 4 hours of recovery after exercise.
3. The first days of low carbohydrate
When you eat little carbohydrate or exercise for a long time, muscle breaks glycogen down for use, and the water that came with it is released and leaves in urine.Weight can drop noticeably within a day or two.
A 1976 metabolic-ward study took this apart and measured it. Six obese volunteers each went through several 10-day periods, and the researchers used energy and nitrogen balance to work out whether each day's loss was water, fat or protein. On the same 800 kcal a day, a ketogenic diet produced an average loss of about 467 g a day, about 61% of it water and about 35% fat; an equal-calorie mixed diet produced about 278 g a day, about 37% water and about 60% fat. The extra weight that came off on the ketogenic diet was mainly water, not extra fat burned; working from these shares, the two diets removed about the same amount of fat per day. The study had only 6 people, and each period lasted only 10 days.
4. Carbohydrate back, water back
Eat carbohydrate again and the glycogen refills, the water comes back with it, and the number on the scale goes up again.In this whole round trip, not a single gram is fat.
Glycogen does not carry only water when it is stored. A short 1992 report notes that glycogen sits in liver, muscle and fat cells in a hydrated form, and that each gram also carries about 0.45 mmol of potassium. From this the authors discuss how much of the weight swing in the first days of dieting comes from glycogen and its water, and how weight shows a rebound that looks exaggerated when carbohydrate is eaten again. These are the authors' discussion points; the report's abstract gives no numerical results, and there was no control group.